Thread:Shanethefilmmaker/@comment-397235-20140829052131/@comment-397235-20140902112426

But the Calamity alters her memories so she probably wouldn't remember her wanting that doll in the first place (since that was a corollary of her dying)...unless the Calamity changed things so she was sick for a few years and missed so much school she was still in 9th (or in this case 10th) grade, which is about the only way this could work without drastically altering their relationship in the first place (by making them not twins), which again messes with the character herself. Plus there's the dramatics problem of the audience already knowing who the Extra is, which is part of the mystery.

The best way I can think of for this to work would be for there to be two (or more) Extras and Jordan is only one of them. So once Kirk figures it out (and I have no idea how he'd do that without Holly's help), he kills her, but since that by itself didn't end the Calamity, everyone still remembers her and Holly sees him as a murderer. Maybe she's still ill, so she still has Color of Death, which is why Holly is hesitant to kill her; I don't know. But like I said, I think she'd make a better cliffhanger than an actual arc.